The Beautification of War: Digital Communications, Public Indifference, Rebel Journalism, and Civilian Resistance in the Age of Meta Wars

These technologies – the dynamic routing of ARPANET is the best-known example – were of course born of military-industrial complex funding and efforts to build “hot potato” communications networks of networks that could survive partial destruction, such as by nuclear war. Without the “modernizing”, real-time, speed-of-light streamlining offered by these technologies originally based on packet switching, decentralized networks, remote login, the conjoining of networks of networks using communication protocols, notably TCP/IP, the United States could not nowadays efficiently and effectively command and manage its 800 military bases in over 75 countries. Without digital communications technologies, including its own global
navigation system Beidou “Big Dipper”, China’s PLA couldn’t operate its Djibouti military base, experiment with sophisticated cyber weapons capable of mimicking, tricking, and confounding the signal systems of enemy satellites, land a spacecraft on the far side of the Moon, or operate its space station Tiangong (Heavenly Palace). Smaller armies are similarly restructured along digital lines: in major reforms of recent years, for instance, the Ukrainian army dispensed with combat units larger than battalions. Its fighting structures became flatter, its command and intelligence operations more tightly connected digitally.

What is more, in the era of meta wars, as you know well, armies’ weapons systems double as lethal digital tools: long-range hypersonic missiles such as Trident 2, Minuteman 3, sea-launched SM-6s, and Russia’s Avangard; AI machine learning systems like Israel’s Habsora “The Gospel”, Lavender and Where’s Daddy? that sift through data, monitor and identify targets, and operate as “mass assassination factories”; killer drones dispatched from the armchairs of distant control rooms; precision-guided bombs; digitally guided, state-of-the-art Stinger and Javelin missiles; bombs disguised as booby-trapped wireless communications tools; Saab’s NLAW anti-tank weapons; Apache attack helicopters whose Hellfire missiles are capable of liquidating targets 11 kilometres distant; machine-gun armed Sharp Claws robots, and wifi operated Mule 200 vehicles stationed by the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) on China’s high-altitude frontier with India are just some of the best-known examples of the digitization of war’s weapons.

Gamification

McLuhan spoke of the coming of war into our living rooms, but he could not have foreseen another development unique to our age of meta wars: the novel ways digital technologies enable the multimedia 3D public representation of war in which governments and armies and various media platforms draw audiences into war’s battlegrounds. We could say that the “common sense” of war is dramatically transformed. War comes to have a meta quality in a second sense. As the Chinese scholar Shi Zhan has pointed out, digitized war undergoes a gamification. It is as if Mark Zuckerberg now designs war reportage; or, looking back, that the meta wars of our age are taking their cue from Neal Stephenson’s science fiction novel Snow Crash (1992), in which digitally networked 3D technologies draw socially connected users into what seem to be “realistic” virtual worlds; or perhaps from Ernest Cline’s novel
Ready Player One (2011), in which individuals inhabit multiple virtual worlds in a single universe dubbed “the OASIS”. For the first time in history, meta wars are coming to have a digitally augmented reality quality. This is true in several senses.

We live in times in which armies train their soldiers to handle the fog and friction of war using battlefield simulator programmes, as the US Marine Corps has done by teaming up with the Prague-based Bohemia Interactive Studio to develop the gaming platform Virtual Battlespace 2, called VBS2. In the age of meta wars, war reporting has also gone digital. A large gaggle of skilled and seasoned journalists and public relations and marketing professionals function as the playwrights of war reporting. Drawing together the online and offline worlds, their job as game creators is to usher audiences into virtual rooms where they “inform” them of the progress of a war. The dramaturgs speak what could be called meta speak. Colonel Natalia Humenyuk, spokeswoman for Operational Command South, tells Ukraine television audiences things like “the counteroffensive in the south of Ukraine is moving forward. The Russian Army is demoralized”. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov chips in: “Our military does not hit social facilities and residential neighbourhoods and does not hit civilians”. There are familiar figures like Biden’s Karine Jean-Pierre and Jake Sullivan, and Mark Regev, an unfunny Melbourne-born spokesman for the Israeli
government, who is proudly on record as saying repeatedly that genocide allegations against Israel are “preposterous” and that the current ICJ case against Israel is in effect the “defence of Hamas”, and that “as a democracy we’re keeping civilian casualties to a bare minimum”.

And, for the first time in the history of war, AI-generated digital spokespersons deliver mainstream media war reports. Ukraine’s Victoria Shi is the pioneer: a character modelled on a Donetsk-born singer and former contestant on Ukraine’s version of The Bachelor reality show, she doubles as a stiff and smoothtalking propagandist who boasts that she is a proponent of “cutting-edge wartime diplomacy”, fluent in 30
languages, and “always looks good in the morning because I do not go out late at night”.

In the age of meta wars, these mainstream media performances are laced with war room briefings by stern-faced, uniformed military commanders, commentaries by “accredited” experts, images of smoke-filled battlegrounds, fighter jets overhead, tanks and troops, wrecked buildings, burning fields, and displaced civilians. Multi-game player dynamics are the norm. Soldiers using fake social media accounts
to conceal their whereabouts demonstrate their prowess to publics back home by uploading images and clips of their strikes and manoeuvrings to Instagram, Twitter, Facebook, and TikTok. Government intelligence directorates call upon citizens trapped in battle zones to identify collaborators and to reveal the enemy’s whereabouts. Civilians are invited into the game rooms. The Russian government approves the use of popular video games such as Roblox and Minecraft (owned by Microsoft) in which Russian soldiers battle against Ukrainian Nazis and conquer Ukraine territory. Civilians join cyber-armies on Telegram Messenger to feed on-the-spot, battlefield intelligence to their armed forces. Vloggers such as TikTok influencer Rom Carmi provide running text and video commentaries. The stories they tell are copied, posted, re-posted, mashed up, liked, disliked, and circulated by mainstream media platforms elsewhere in the world.

Not to be forgotten are the lone shooter star performers. Almost every day or evening a president of a war-ravaged country who was previously a comedian and television actor, the star of a series called Servant of the People, delivers moral appeals for military help to domestic and global audiences. The president’s staged performances are carefully tailored to their target audiences. At home, he says things like: “I thank
each of our combat brigades, all the soldiers and commanders who are destroying the enemy with all their might and, in particular, using our drone capabilities with precision”. When abroad, what is said to the members of the Knesset (Russia is preparing a “final solution” for Ukraine) differs in tone and substance from what is told by video link to parliaments in Athens (Ukraine is one of the Orthodox countries that was Christianized by the Greeks), in Ottawa (where he received several standing ovations during a speech laced with references to Vancouver, the CN Tower in Toronto, and other cities and landmarks), and in New York (where the president rejects Chinese and Brazilian peace plans to end a three-year war by denouncing
their diplomats as apologists of colonialism).

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10